In Great Britain, the historic cradle of liberty and sanctum of freedom of expression, it appears that you can no longer refer to Arab depravity in the slaughter of an Israeli family — including a three month-old baby — as they slept without someone going to the police to get you arrested for racism.
This is what happened to me. I wrote on my blog about the ‘the moral depravity of the Arabs’ who had murdered Udi and Ruth Fogel and their three children, 11-year-old Yoav, four-year-old Elad and three-month-old Hadas in their home in the Samarian neighbourhood of Itamar, near Nablus, by cutting their throats while most of them were asleep.
I also pointed the finger for this atrocity at the ‘savagery’ of the Palestinian Authority, whose educational materials along with the mosques and TV stations under its control incite frenzied hatred of Jews; which teaches its children that the highest aspiration is to murder Israelis; and which glorifies those who perpetrate such unspeakable acts by naming squares and public places after them.
Next thing I knew was that the Guardian ran a story saying I was being investigated by the UK Press Complaints Commission, which had received two complaints about my remarks – and I had also been reported to the Bedfordshire police for racism.
This came as something of a surprise. If I was indeed being investigated, no-one had seen fit to tell me about it. Indeed, at time of writing I still have not heard whether either of these bodies is investigating these complaints at all.
Stranger still was the involvement of the Bedfordshire police. I do not live in Bedfordshire, an area north of London. I have never had anything to do with the place. What could my remarks about the Itamar massacre possibly have to do with Bedfordshire?
A clue lay in the involvement in the Guardian story of a prominent British Muslim activist named Inayat Bunglawala. It was he who had reported me to the Bedfordshire police – and he lives in Bedfordshire.
It would appear that having taken exception to my blog, Bunglawala went to his local police force to complain about my views and expected them to take action against me as a result.
His complaint was that I had made a ‘generalised racist outburst against Arabs as a whole’. But this was ridiculous. I was obviously referring specifically to the perpetrators of the Itamar massacre and to the Palestinian Authority which incites such deeds Bunglawala claimed that if anyone had referred to the ‘moral depravity of the Jews’ and described them as being ‘savages’ they would face prosecution for racist hate speech.
Does one really have to spell this out? Jews don’t go round murdering innocents in cold blood and cutting the throats of three-month old babies. And this was not a one-off. The Arab and Muslim world glorifies the killing of Jews.
Sweets are routinely handed round in rejoicing at the murder of Israeli civilians. And from Arab and Muslim society pours an unstoppable torrent of deranged, Nazi-style vilification of Jews which fuels the genocidal hysteria behind such attacks.
All of this, plus the fact that Arabs have been murdering Jews in the land of Israel for more than nine decades in order to drive them out, means that to refer to ‘Arab moral depravity’ is more than justified.
But my real crime was surely to refer to an Arab atrocity at all and describe it in correct moral terms. For in our politically correct society, any such criticism amounts to ‘anti-Arab racism’ – and is infinitely more reprehensible than slitting the throats of three sleeping children and their parents.
History does not yet record whether the Bedfordshire police will take the slightest notice of Bunglawala. But to understand how the police could have been dragged into this at all, it is necessary to appreciate the grip on British institutions of politically correct ‘victim culture’.
This embodies the Marxist doctrine that groups without power are invariably the victims of groups with power. The ‘powerless’ victims can never be held responsible for what they do; the fault must always lie with their ‘powerful’ oppressors.
Because subjectivity rules, feelings trump everything else. So hurting the feelings of a ‘powerless victim’ group becomes a crime. The giving of offence becomes a criminal offence.
Accordingly, British police forces have established ‘hate crime’ units to police the giving of offence against a wide range of ‘victim’ groups covering ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation or disability.
Into this Orwellian universe has stepped radical Islam. Muslim activists have exploited the hysteria over ‘Islamophobia’ and racism to represent any criticism of Islam as a hate-crime and thus suppress necessary debate about Islamic extremism.
But the grotesque irony of Bunglawala’s complaints about me is that he himself has displayed profoundly anti-Jewish and anti-western views.
He believes Britain should become an Islamic society — though not, he hastens to reassure us, through violence. He has described Osama bin Laden as a ‘freedom fighter’ and reveres Sheikh Yusuf Qaradawi, who has issued fatwas calling for jihad against Israel and the Jews and authorised suicide bombing attacks.
He described three Jewish TV executives as all belonging to ‘the tribe of Judah’, whose close friendship gave the lie to a ‘free media’. And he also claimed that the ‘Zionist movement’ was ‘at the core of international banking and commerce’.
The third leg of this very crooked stool, however, is the Guardian newspaper (where in another life I happened to be employed for around two decades).
The Guardian is virulently hostile to Israel. Like other British media, it reported the Itamar massacre by effectively blaming the Fogel family of ‘hard-line settlers’ for their own slaughter. Its opinion pages regularly read like the house journal of Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood.
When Bunglawala contacted it, the paper simply ran as fact his claims that I was being ‘investigated’– thus creating an instant smear.
One might think that self-styled progressives would shun someone with such bigoted and reactionary views. But today the left marches shoulder to shoulder with radical Islam. Heck, what’s a little thing like the Muslim attitude to gays and women (kill ’em, stone ‘em) when the great common aim is the collapse of western civilisation?
Thus the ultra-progressive Guardian has made itself the patsy of a reactionary with deeply questionable attitudes. Far from upholding freedom of speech against such people who pose a mortal threat to western liberty, the Guardian is putting itself in the forefront of the movement to shut down dissent.
But then, the radical Islamist onslaught is a perfect fit with the Manichean perspective of the left, which categorises all who are not of the left as beyond the pale altogether and uses tactics of smears, demonisation and character assassination that were once associated with Stalinist totalitarianism.
And today the Guardian, BBC and other media use those very same tactics against Israel itself. They sanitise the crimes of the Arab and Muslim world while skewing the facts to demonise, dehumanise and delegitimise Israel.
Britain is leading the way in tearing up western cultural norms and with them its ancient liberties. It has become the global hub of ‘lawfare’, the use of the libel laws by Muslim extremists and their sympathisers to shut down debate.
It is where to tell the truth about genocidal Arab aggression against Israel is today to be dismissed as an extremist or damned as a bigot. And it is where the police are called upon to treat as a crime an expression of moral outrage at a depraved campaign of genocidal incitement and mass murder.
It is not I who am in the dock, but Britain itself.







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
88 Comments
I forever thank God I live this side of the pond. Oh, how the mighty have fallen, not with a bang, but a wimper.
If I was indeed being investigated, no-one had seen fit to tell me about it.
———————————————————————————————————————
Not anymore with their anti-boogey man laws, AKA Patriot act and the likes. Too much PC garbage and they know it. It almost seems as if they want us to die. They won't recognize the 800lb gorilla in the corner…
It is part and parcel with the mentality that said "Oh, dear! If only we could get them to like us!" after 9/11. That's almost diagonally opposed to "Speak softly but carry a big stick," isn't it?
Investigated for racism? Whuh? Is there really laws on the books in GB that criminalizes such a thing?
What a sick anemic society our cousins across the Atlantic have become. Melanie Phillips is a national treasure of truth and intellect to that nation. And yet members of religiously medieval, and Seventh century cultures can incite bureaucrats, and law enforcement to turn on their own people. (I know, it's not confirmed yet) For offering an opinion in the "free" press. If only the toothless, unarmed, morally confused authority, that is supposed to be a government could have protected the streets of London, businesses, landmarks, and citizens from the violent anarchists last week. Like they always boot-lickingly protect adult Muslim feelings.
I would have never thought it were medically possible to be emasculated, neutered, and impotent and still be a wanker at the same time. The UK has done it.
Can you have him investigated for chutzpah?
It was the Fogels who were victims of hate crimes. If Bunglawala doesn't like to be associated with cowardly and bloodthirsty animals who kill for Islam, maybe he should renounce Islam, or work toward its reformation.
How is it possible that you connect the Patriot act with something like this?
"Bunglawala claimed that if anyone had referred to the ‘moral depravity of the Jews’ and described them as being ‘savages’ they would face prosecution for racist hate speech." Never would that happen, and quite frankly it shouldn't. That UK authorities even can investigate charges of "racism" and there is a press complaint department with police power shows how close Britain has come to totalitarianism. We all know that if a UK rabbi complained about a Muslim's anti-Semitic remarks, the Jew would be investigated.
Any issue of the Guardian could be mistaken for a 1942 Berlin rag. The only reason the Guardian would take offense at that characterization is because the Molotov-Ribbentropp Pact didn't hold.
As a huge fan of your work, Ms. Phillips, let me suggest it is time for UK subjects to make fools of their government, not that it doesn't do a fine job. I realize you don't have the First Amendment protections, but you do have a court system that hasn't totally adopted Sharia. You also have Plaintiff-friendly libel laws (also dangerous to liberty, but use the weapon you have at hand). Sue the bastards.
Certainly for use of the word in neighborhoods with minarets.
Moral clarity, and truth calling out the hypocrites of the world, courtesy of the folks on the Big's. Well said Don'tTread!
You get home from a long day of Jihad and all you want to do is kick off your sandals and watch a little al-jazeera, maybe read the guardian and call it a day but boy o boy, it sure is lonely in your tent. Well not anymore! Welcome to "Goats R Us", your one stop shop for the best looking and most subserviant goats on the market. Each of our goats is hand selected ( and tested) by an imam for it's hind quarters and overall appearance and they all come with a money back guarantee. Now every jihadi can end those cold lonely nights in this ancient isalmic tradition. Call "Goats R Us" today.
Once again, so the Muslims understand this point…… Israeli Jews and Arabs are the same Race of People…. they are both Semites.
Muslim is Not A Race Of People. …. just as Judaism is Not A Race Of People.
To say that one Semite savagely murdered another Semite (even am entire Semite Family) is not Racism.
From where I sit, it looks like the British government has decided that the British people are neither fit to live nor to protect. A crime no longer is in an of itself an issue – it's who commits the act that determines whether or not it is criminal. It's a strange set of values that includes surrendering to a people who do not share them. When the Britons are extinct, who will receive the kudos for their sticking to their principles?
Oh…and the Falkland Islanders had better pray that Argentina leaves them alone.
If either extreme, left or right, were to completely have their way; we'd have the 'thought police' here too. Political correctness is the gateway to such censorship. You may not agree with the Westboro Baptist Church (I hate what they do), but at least we are free in the U.S. to speak freely even if someone is offended.
"It has become the global hub of ‘lawfare’"
Amen brother.
Loser pays needs to apply to all non criminal cases. Otherwise the left can finance groups to bleed you to death with legal fees.
Kind of glad Winston isn't around to see it. On the other hand, they could use another Churchill to get them roused before it's too late (if it isn't already).
Well…so far anyway.
Government control is easily perverted.
And that's why I'm grateful that the Supreme Court recently upheld the right of even that vile Wesboro "church" to free speech.
Who would walk shoulder to shoulder with a Paki Cleric over Veena Malik? Forget the men in ProgressiveLand. Really. If you want to associate yourself as a proud member of the Ghey Parade then by all means have at it.
But the women…? How do you Progressive women live with yourselves? Just leave the USA already.
Veena Malik? YEAH BABY! Now THAT'S purely USA. Not that Valerie Jarrett crap.
Oh, our Marxist contingent is working tirelessly to implement the Police State Paradise of Merry Ol' England here in the USA. Wait to thank God when we throw dirt on the last of those bastards, and pray to God the British people have it left in them to stop the insanity there. I suspect they do.
I thought I remembered this Bunglawala's name. Seems he's been up to mischief for quite a long time.
If we keep doing nothing we are going to end up like the once great country of England. Remember the scumbag Muslims will never give up unless we stomp a boot on their necks. Harsh but the truth. Kind of like the Marxist scum in the Democratic party these people are only a couple stages bellow the Muslims in violence.
That columnist will have more gratis barristers wanting to represent him than any other case. Show the terrorists just where they stand in England's eyes and in the world's eyes. Terrorism is the bullseye now and they'll never escape. The world is united against them now. Islam is NOT a Religion. It is a criminal enterprise and needs to be extinguished worldwide. That's my idea of Globalism!
Since when has Islam become a Race?
It's not the first time Britain has been conquered by barbarians – it may be the last time.
Brits are "winghers". Lost in their cups, the wimper along toward eventual destruction. Its o.k. though, they have their toddies. Are there any good men left in that silly little island off the coast of France?
Maybe she should start writing stories about the British government banning Michael Savage, since she's already being investigated and they already put his name on the 'terrorism' list.
Well let's see…..
First the British Government BANS Michael Savage.
What did the British People do when Mr. Savage was banned…???
NOTHING….Strike ONE.
Than they released a Muslim Terrorist to Libya who killed 180 Brits, Americans and others and WHAT Happened?
NOTHING… StrikeTwo
Than the British people allow SHARIA to be practiced instead of British Law, what do the Brits do???
Nothing…… Strike three….YOU ARE OUT!
You Brits better WAKE UP…FIRST THING ..
FIGHT FOR SAVAGE….UNDO THAT INJUSTICE…SEND A MESSAGE…SAVAGE IS WORTH FIGHTING FOR>>>
fallen in government BUT NOT THE PEOPLE the EDL is making headway ….
the people of the UK are sick to death of PC
Muslim radicalism is a mess of potage, with a dash of piss, in a pie case of crap
Many Muslims have learned to use the victimhood status to their benefit and are playing off the infidels they have every intention of killing when the day comes.
you are correct the government has failed …. but the EDL is on the rise
Okay, I know why we Americans are supposed to be tolerant of Muslims and other religions who want to kill us; our president is a Muslim! Be prepared…they are going to try to take over the WORLD! God help us all!!
Sir, yes there are many, they are organising, but under great adversity from the morally weak UK government, and you may whimper soon …. note how the silent invasion from that cesspit hole of mexico has now got @15million undocumeted "troops" into your country, note how you have more hispanic speakers in Texas schools than English speakers.
Note you are tolerating enclosed townships in the USA where only islamic people are permitted, …. Sir also note that the MS-13 now have a recognised (by LEO) command and control system throughout the USA with members who have gone through military training before returning to the gangs. These gangs outnumber the do-nut eating, well overweight, elected Sheriffs and Marshals and are certainally better equiped that the majority of normal street cops. Please do not think that the SWAT teams will be of any use in a confrontation with the gang members or Islamic extremists, both have nothing to loose going all out against family loving SWAT members who want to get home at night. (don't get me wrong they are brave members of the police force and first class at the job they are trained for, but street gang warfare is not that)
Please also note the PC way that CAIR is slowly enforcing on your cities and local governments, the way they have scared the real journalists away from telling about the influx of Muslims. also how stories of sleeper cells are not permitted in the MSM did I mention that the people who try to list each and every crime committed in the name of Islam on US soil are censored or made to look idiots.
And lastly for this posting anyway how Islamic Law was recently permitted to be used in a Florida court to the extent that US law was thrown out ……
It's good to see Melanie Phillips in Big Journalism. I've enjoyed reading her columns in the UK's Daily Mail. This is a harbinger of what's going to destroy us if we do not act against this kind of judicial terrorism.
everyone who writes here is investigated ………..
My sympathies. I'm sure it's coming to a theatre near us.
Once proud England, how far you have fallen……………………….
Melanie, take the first plane THE HECK OUT OF THERE!
Nuke them from orbit, it's the only way to be sure. Oh, never mind, they hate nukes as well as Jews. Carry on then old chap, let the aliens parasitize them to death.
To "tolerate" those who refuse to accept a moral responsibility to "tolerate" you is to be complicit in your own destruction. And if you do not trouble yourself to defend your own life why should anyone else be expected to do so? This is cultural suicide abetting a cultural invasion.
At about the same time racism and bigotry came to mean the same thing, I expect. Teach the children that "proper grammar isn't the eleventh commandment" (as one of my English professors in college was fond of saying) and you can proceed to muddy the commonly accepted meanings of words until they come to actually mean nothing at all. Then you can engage in linguistic gymnastics to your heart's content and never be held accountable for what you have (or haven't) said. Liberals call this concept "nuance".
that's the funniest response I have had in a while ….. well done
Being on this side of the pond doesn't mean diddly. Our MSM is trying has been trying so desperately for years to follow in the footsteps of the Guardian and the BBC.
One of the major weapons in the propaganda war against Israel is the “Remember these Children” website which compares the numbers of Arab children who have been killed in the conflicts to the number of Jewish children murdered by terrorists. The Arab list totals 1,437 since 2000 and the Jewish list totals 130. Not withstanding that such reporting is unsubstantiated, After visiting the site, I noticed that according to this report, most of the Israeli children were murdered in drive by shootings and human bombs exploding themselves in restaurants, buses and markets. In other words, the Arab terrorists targeted those children and murdered them in cold blood. For all of the Arab children, on the other hand, the site identifies the causes of death as gun shot wounds or explosions during the firefights with Arab Hamas fighters. What were their children doing in the middle of a war zone? That is clear and convincing evidence that the Hamas thugs where using the local children as human shields. Soldiers are trained to return fire when fired upon. The bushwhacking urban guerrillas who fire at enemy troops from a neighborhood full of children are the ones causing the deaths of those children. More at http:moshesharon.worpress.com
About the same time that liberals decided to scream "Racist" at anyone who disagrees with them.
Here! Here! It's good vs evil, no matter where you live.
These are laws YOU JEWS passed to suppress the speech of Whites who dared challenge your lies. Now you don't like it being used against YOU.
There is a reason that freedom of speech is in our 1st Amendment. No society, be it democracy or republic, will remain free without it. It is the foundation of our Republic. Progressives, Marxists, communists , socialists are constantly trying to erode our freedom of speech. The whole Hate crime garbage and hate speech garbage and Racist comments garbage is the way they try to legislate against freedom of speech. We have constant battles here trying to defend it. The UK has bigger problems in that area.
Another weapon they use is the Multiculturalism garbage. It is also used to erode freedom of speech. Just ask Geert Wilders how well that works out.
Can you just imagine an Islamist agreeing with the famous quote "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it"?
SHE WUZ ARRESTED FOR RACISMS
They ( the left ) can't handle the TRUTH….
which makes…
creditability lost…
Canada, too.
Yup, good ol' Bungholio is still loud and proud…and now screeching "raaaaaacist!" His next screech will be his usual one- the death threats <sigh>
Thanks for the link, Joe- I was sitting here doing the "now I *know* I've mocked that name before, but where?"
Winston Churchill must be spinning so fast in his grave, if he were connected to a turbine it would generate enough energy to power most of Europe!
The only western nation that I know of that does not criminalize its citizens for thought crimes is the U.S.
Mel: Glad to see you posting on a US site. I have been reading your blog for years now. Stay safe and if things get too crazy, come on over and stay for a long while.
why no story about those kill teams in Afghanistan? Maybe because they look to much like most of the posters here?
I know it's a waste of time and energy even to reply, but someone just has to mention, fu, that you are too stupid for words.
The hatred you spew is really getting tiresome. You are a bigot and a vile person. Please go away.
We can't take four more years of Obama, he would love to see the Brit's go down, he hates them almost as much as he hates the US.
Evil comes cloaked in many forms..Political Correctness is just one. Bugholio is an evil little man with a sordid past. The part that amazes me is that the Brits give his voice credence!
Islam, founded by an illiterate pedophile, is a blood lust cult, they use children as human shields and oppress women because they are afraid of them. Islam is a boil on the arse of society!
TWO complaints to the police, sounds like the British constabulary consists mostly of nimrods with no common sense, sharia is the law in GB.
DEATH TO JIHAD. ISLAM DESERVES TO BE A PILLAR OF SALT. EXTINCT. FOR THEIR MASS MURDER OF CIVILIZATION.
THERE ARE NO INVESTIGATORS…ONLY JIHAD. DEATH TO JIHAD!
WE ARE…THEY WILL DIE! DEATH TO JIHAD.
They're trying, but they WILL fail.
Years back, there was a mighty oak tree on my in laws' farm. It was one of the largest I had ever seen. There was also a wisteria vine growing among the branches. They were warned that the wisteria needed to be removed, but it was a lovely sight in the Spring. Needless to say, the oak died and the wisteria is all that is left.
Melanie, it may be time to get that ticket to some South American beach and some face change surgery . . .
Stay safe.
Britain; the new France.
Let's face the facts in Britains case it is to late Islam has won. And I hope Peter King has a ton more congressional hearings.
You're welcome, Pixie.
At first I didn't want to link to LGF, but I figured, wtf – that was some genuinely good sleuthing by Charles, and he deserves the credit, regardless of what he's become since.
One needs to use the same strategy against Mr Bagalalalala. Start complaining about his HATE speach. Put him under investigation!!!
it's the jews <skip>…..it's the jews <skip>….it's the jews<skip>
there goes that darned ol' record player again!
It's not so much an odd way of thinking, it is by design. When they have no argument to defend their ideas or when they are losing the argument, they fabricate a motivation for their opponent's ideas………..RACIST! It's the Alinsky tactic of ridiculing and marginalizing the opponent, because they can't win the argument.
…I like to think of islam as the sh!tstain on mankinds' underwear.
And those who dis-allow others for calling islam for what it is as the festering, burning, itching hemorhoid on the @ss of mankinds' quest for life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness and all the freedoms that come with it!
"Jewish" can be both a race and a religion. The Jews are in some cases genetically distinct from Arabs. There are genetic diseases specific to certain Jews such as the Ashkenazi.
In all likelihood we will win. I even give the Brits a shot at it. But give these evil bastards credit, they can adapt from communist-coddlers to pro-jihadists, whatever it takes, to destroy the West. Complacency is their friend, and for much too long the UK was complacement. That would have happened here but/for the advent of alternative media. The average American leftist despises FOX News much more than a jihadist.
"politically correct society"
Not politically correct society but rather politically coercive. The Left believes they can partner with Muslims to undermine Western societies to help further their "progressive" social engineering policies. They will only succeed in helping the Muslims destroy everyone.
LGF *used* to be worthwhile, but then…well…you know <sigh> But I agree, he did do a great job of investigating that "charlie foxtrot".
But when they "flip the switch"…they *really* flip.
I just had a thought, but it might be illegal…
Europeans are just Jew-hating bigots. It's their culture. It's their history. It's just who they are.
Want bias? How about this? No one – no one! mentioned that the cowards in the Republican party left funding for NPR and all public broadcasting, including Pacifica intact, something that has been carefully hidden – hey Bbart – how about mentioning it?.
Like the people here in the USA, they will sit up and take notice when it starts costing them MONEY.
RITA PAD is the largest manufacturer of pad printing machines in India and has a formidable
50% market share. -chic Ferrari HoodiesWe offer pad printing, printing machine, laser marking machine, digital
printing machine etc.
this is something unethical
Mike
Auto Glass Repair Services
Auto Glass Repair in Washington DC
Auto Glass Repair in Baltimmore MD
Auto Glass Repair in Rockville MD
Auto Glass Repair in Alexandria VA
Auto Glass Repair in Fairfax VA
Auto Glass Repair in Gaithersburg MD
Criticizing someone is not a crime i believe whether are they terrorist or not.
Ac Repair in alexandria va
Ac Repair in arlington va
Ac Repair in reston va
Refrigerator Repair in alexandria va
Refrigerator Repair in arlington va
Refrigerator Repair in reston va
You must be logged in to post a comment.