Sarah Palin practices politics as lap dance, and we’re the suckers who pay the price. Members of our jaded national press corps eagerly stuff hundred-dollar bills into her G-string, even as they wink at one another to show that they don’t take her seriously.
- Joe McGinniss, The Rogue: Searching for the Real Sarah Palin

It seemed odd that Joe McGinniss’s new biography of Sarah Palin had received so many poor reviews from media outlets typically hostile to the former Alaska governor.
After I read it, the reason became clear: The Rogue is so lurid, malicious, and self-evidently false that Palin’s opponents fear it will undermine their cause. It also reveals more about the shared mindset of the left and the mainstream media than many journalists would care to admit.
McGinniss seems driven by an irrational hatred of Palin. That is apparent from the nasty charges he makes about her, which are not only sensational but also self-contradictory. His malevolent accusations evoke George Orwell’s observation on antisemitism: “Obviously the charges made about Jews are not true. They cannot be true, partly because they cancel out, partly because no one people could have such a monopoly of wickedness.”
Take McGinniss’s most infamous claim, leaked days before The Rogue appeared in stores–the accusation that Palin had sex with basketball player Glen Rice in 1987. The charge appears in the book exactly one page after McGinniss claims Palin declined to enroll at the Hilo campus of the University of Hawaii because “the many people of color there made her nervous,” and that she later abandoned the Honolulu campus because “[t]here were people of color…even on Waikiki Beach.” McGinniss attempts to explain the abrupt transition by speculating that she might have become “a basketball groupie who’d begun to find black men attractive.” And then, on the very next page after that, he quotes an unnamed “friend” who claimed that Palin “totally flipped out” about her alleged encounter with Rice: “I fucked a black man! She was just horrified. She couldn’t believe that she’d done it,” the alleged “friend” claims (original emphasis).
Other contradictions recur throughout the book. McGinniss can’t decide, for example, whether Palin was a “housewife who happened to be governor” (quoting Gary Wheeler, a state employee whose job she cut), or that Palin neglected her maternal duties such that “the children literally would have a hard time finding enough to eat” (quoting an unnamed “friend”). The only common theme is McGinniss’s palpable hatred for Palin.
(more…)