A federal immigration judge in Tennessee has awarded political asylum to a German couple that was threatened by the German government with having their children forcibly removed from their home because the couple chose homeschooling instead of sending them to state approved schools.
Uwe Romeike may now stay as a legal resident in Morrisstown, Tennessee, where the family moved in 2008 after being threatened by German authorities.

The Associated Press was one of the few Old Media outlets covering this story. Of the Romeike’s plight, the AP reported:
The Romeikes took their three oldest children out of school in Bietigheim-Bissingen in the state of Baden-Wuerttemberg in 2006. Romeike said the couple was fined the equivalent of about $10,000 over a two-year period.
Mr. Romeike told reporters: ”I think it’s important for parents to have the freedom to choose the way their children can be taught.”
This isn’t the only case of a German family facing the wrath of state sponsored schools negating the rights of parents to guide their own children’s education. In 2009 the Wunderlich family had their children seized by French officials at the behest of German authorities for the family’s violation of official German schooling policies.
Sadly, about the only people reporting on these incidents seem to be Christian groups and homeschooling networks on the Internet. Groups like the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA). As mentioned above, the AP has a story that has made its way around the wires, too, but there doesn’t seem to be much independent coverage of this by the Old Media.
This seems odd since it is quite an interesting story where it concerns international relations. The HSLDA says that this ruling is “embarrassing for Germany.” That may be but the rest of the media is silent.
“This decision finally recognizes that German homeschoolers are a specific social group that is being persecuted by a Western democracy,” said Mike Donnelly, staff attorney and director of international relations for Home School Legal Defense Associaton. “It is embarrassing for Germany, since a Western nation should uphold basic human rights, which include allowing parents to raise and educate their own children. This judge understood the case perfectly, and he called Germany out. We hope this decision will cause Germany to stop persecuting homeschoolers,” he added.

The HSLDA also notes that homeschoolers in Germany face increasing amounts of persecution.
“There is no safety for homeschoolers in Germany,” Donnelly said. “The two highest courts in Germany have ruled that it is acceptable for the German government to ‘stamp out’ homeschoolers as some kind of ‘parallel society.’ The reasoning is flawed. The fact is that homeschoolers are not a parallel society. Valid research shows that homeschoolers excel academically and socially. German courts are simply ignoring the truth that exists all over the world where homeschooling is practiced. They need to look beyond their own borders.”
This newest development is not being covered much, though ABC, and the AP covered the Romeike family back in March as the court case came before immigration officials.
Some might think that a democratic western nation losing some of its citizens to another democratic western nation through a case of political asylum would be quite a story for the media? Unfortunately, the story has an element of homeschooling so the story stays under the radar. And there certainly seems to be a bias of omission being committed against homeschooling in the American media.






Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
88 Comments
It does make one wonder, if we in the U.S.A., are going to be given the same 'no choice' as this family??!! With the socialists in charge, this would be their way!
Good thing they didn't move to the Peoples Republic of Kalifornia! That would have been out of the frying pan, and into the fire!
I kid. But only a little.
I have friends who home school their two pre-teen children. They exhibit such as wonderful naivete, in the best sense of the word. They don't pre-judge new experiences with the jadedness seen in so many kids these days. They have such a sweet innocence.
Hey Germany! Hitler would be proud of your decision to stamp out individualism in your society. The Hitler Youth Corps had nothing on you! Shame.
i don't know why they moved to the u.s., it is only a matter of time until the "one" changes our laws to do that here. i mean how can he propagandize all of our youth in re-education camps, i mean schools, if they are not all in school? home schoolers are not being taught the essetials of education. they no nothing of diversity, gay acceptance, abortion as a only option, fisting, and those wonderful songs about dear leader. reading, writing, science, and history are not a well balanced education, they need to be taught how to stand in long lines for gubmint handouts, how to punch only democrat on a ballot, and how to humilliate anybody who thinks capitalism is a good thing.
The current model for public schools started in Germany so the actions of the German courts do not surprise me. Good for the Romeike family, I hope they enjoy the freedom America has to offer for many many years to come. I hope we all enjoy them for the next dozen centuries.
“Gimme a Break!”. Where’s John Stossel when we need him most? Hopefully he’ll follow this story and interview the family…
The next ten months will tell. If we can make it safely to the next election without a major power grab to the private sector, we may make it. It won't be without tons of work in the future to take back our country though, not to mention the two more years left of the "One". At least he will be a lame duck.
We definitely need to be on our knees begging God to spare us this invasion from within. I am feeling more optimistic, we are awake with eyes wide open….
Let us not be naiive! Our current administration in Washington has an underlying theme in every pronouncement. One people, one country, one government! – That is more than a vague translation of Ein Volk, ein Land, ein Fuehrer!
Next will come: A government job is liberating?
From a comment I posted just yesterday:
. . . it's(home schooling) pretty much a state issue and pushback against unreasonable regulations has managed to hold back the tide, but rest assured that HS is on the top ten enemy list with social progressives. Any deviation from their view of the perfect society is like a pebble in their shoe. And there are many working behind the scene across the country to regulate to death home-schooling. Once again, vigilance, vigilance, vigilance.
You know how the progressives love to look to Europe for their 'enlightened' ways.
"Sadly, about the only people reporting on these incidents seem to be Christian groups and homeschooling networks on the Internet."
Happily, those groups are quite large, and growing all the time.
In the 1980s, homeschoolers in the US were routinely fined and jailed. Home School Legal Defense fought many cases and slowly the tide turned. Homeschooling is now legal in all 50 states and there are established court decisions (including a ruling of the Supreme Court) that support parent's rights to control the education of their children. California did try to place limits on homeschoolers a year or two ago. There was a national outcry. There were friend of the court briefs filed by the governor, the ACLU and even the state dept. of education on behalf of homeschoolers.
However, the teacher's union and socialists are as hostile as ever to homescholers. They would love to change our laws. But they can not. The US Constitution was written to grant freedom to its citizens. So, the new tactic is to place our laws under the authority of the United Nations. Then, they can do whatever they want. So, keep your eye on those UN resolutions that people keep arguing for us to ratify. If the UN treaty on the Rights of the Child passes, the parents in the United States lose homeschooling freedom.
Home schooling does not fit with the liberal socialist agenda.
Check out these quotes from famous Commies past…I didn't make stuff up…
If you doubt this is what's going on with OUR Regressives, then you are not paying adequate attention…
Where is the American Media on this? Covering Tiger Woods I guess.
Don't you know that all Homeschoolers are a bunch of Survivalist, Obama Hating, Fundamentalist Christian yahoos?
To the Romeike family, welcome to America. Things will change in 2010 and 2012 where you will enjoy the full freedom of Homeschooling/Educating your children as you see fit.
The "antis" like to call that naivete and innocence "poor socialization." I guess if you're not completely morally bankrupt, you're not evolving. My wife's daughter's boys are home schooled–I know what you're saying and I would guess they can probably outperform most other kids educated by the Democrat school system (They've controlled the funding for about 60 years, now).
You're right–they just got a reprieve.
Are you crazy.How can you let a white person come into our country.Would it not hurt the bolshevik agenda of flooding the country with minorities and absolutely no whites.Wow!How can you do this to us bolsheviks.I am going to speak to Ruth Ginsburg about this.This is illegal.
Welcome to the USA, Romeikes.
America will be stronger for having quality people who have the strength of their convictions to education and freedom.
Let's not forget that state schooling in Germany was instituted by Otto von Bismarck *specifically* to create obedient, conformist workers and soldiers to serve the Reich.
You are spot on as usual Randy12. Thankfully Home Schooling has been mandated in each state seperately and the HSLDA has been representing Home Schoolers for about thirty years (a strong history of precedence). There are states that are very difficult to home school in, but others that leave you pretty much alone. We are really blessed in the state of Washington to have one of the best laws on the books. For a progressive state, it really is amazing that home schoolers are left to self regulate as long as they partake in annual testing. The annual testing results are generally off the chart for most kids (what a surprise) so there is rarely a challenge to HS in this state. I thank God for that.
I think we will win this battle and we will be able to hack back the intrusive government control we are currently watching flood our lives. Americans do not want to be Europeans, that is why we left in the first place….we have a fierce independence and vigilance is in our DNA.
In the barren future all fertile women will be imprisoned for use in reproduction by the elite, just like The Handmaid's Tale. Their children will be taken from them as soon as they're born, so enjoy "your" children while you can.
The Progressives know far better than we, and they'll have all the gummit jobs and money.
Conservatism. Christianity. Freedom. Home schooling. This story just doesn't fit the MSM meme.
The United Nations is daily attacking Homeschoolers this great Family is only the tip of the iceberg.
CHeck out the UN's CRC (convention of the rights of the child) at http://www.parentalrights.org and sign the petition to get a constitutional amendment to protect US parents ..there's like 118+ house members and also senators on board.
The private sector works with the government to grab power from the people, not the private sector. Witness the bailouts.
Indeed, you can not even study history there. Well, not one event in history – everything can be questioned except for one thing. Weird, huh?
last but not least :
" He alone, who owns the youth, gains the future."
~ Adolf Hitler ~
Indeed – which makes it all the more shocking that Americans were hoodwinked to fight for communism during WWII!
Gummit jobs can be defunded….I am still hopeful "We the people" are awake….
Amen Sister!
I'm sure the Nazis has had many poignant and colorful expressions in their quest for the ultimate totalitarian state…I was listing the Russian Komrad Commies/Regressves thoughts…
But thanks…
The MSM is as good as dead. Only news acceptable to libtards will be printed. Only the news that's feck to print. Thank god for the internet.
Yes, it is in our DNA and if they want to pick a fight with homeschoolers, they will learn what a real fight is.
More to your point about DNA, we are friends with a German homeschool family who left there 20 years ago because of the restrictions even then. (The "private" schools were so regulated that they had to choose their curriculum from several state-approved choices.) Last year when this administration came in, I asked him what he thought would happen. His response, "I'm not worried. Americanz, zay love zeer freedomz!" I think he is right.
I see you're wearing your brown shirt this morning….Very fashionable….And the FONZ in this matching armband…Lovely..
I own a business and have recieved no bailouts… so much for your theories.
I believe it was WITH the Commies AGAINST the greater evil of the Nazis…Something like, the enemy of my enemy is a temporary friend and useful tool…
Look at those pictures. Those kids look like they're being punished. They MUST be getting a real education. Good for those parents. Make them study all day long!
That this family leaves Germany to escape their country's control over education seems ironic, the past comes back to haunt. The deception that Nazism was a right-wing movement and not of the left was well crafted. Progressive educational tactics were honed in Germany at the time.
– The whole ugly truth about how American Progressives directly inspired Adolf Hitler and his Reich, is contained in a masterpiece of writing by Edwin Black, War Against The Weak. –
note: your Clint Eastwood avatar was a stroke – my mind reads your posts in ol' Clint's voice ~ " In this world there's two kinds of people, my friend. Those with loaded guns, and those who dig. You dig. ~
Randy….
Which movie did I say that in?…I'm gettin on in years and don't remember so well…
"The Good,The Bad, and You (old fart)
Much obliged…son..But I remember being "the GOOD" …maybe not..been awhile..
Germany's loss is our gain. I am sure that this beautiful family will be a productive part of the US society, unlike some of the trash we currently let in.
Back then you were Clint.
One issue I would like to see pursued by the new conservative/Tea Party movement is school choice! The public schools have become a tool of the progressive left in brainwashing the students. Public institutions have become social labratories. Obama is going to use this as a tool, from the saul Alinsky playbook!
I think that is a little far fetched. Even though I am a homeschooler, I would never go to that extreme of a comparison. Hitler, really??????
I agree it would be a great platform item in the future. Right now the Tea Party has to at least take back the House in November, so that we can lame duck the current president, then prepare for a new president in 2012. Everything in it's time. We have to focus on taking back the government right now.
One of the teens was removed from the home & placed in a mental institution for revering her father too much. This was a very serious issue & much more than just not being able to home school.
Yes. It's a concept almost unrecognizable now. Children who are…children. Unencumbered by the horrors of dying polar bears, they might actually enjoy life for a brief period of time!
it is happening all the time. Here is an example of which happened in my town http://www.wickedlocal.com/cohasset/news/educatio...
No they DO NOT look like they are being punished! They look like they are actually studying!
I'm a ditto with JimF.
You know, when the sun comes up, you can take off the night blinders.
I think that was sarcasm from bet0001970, so you're both 100% right.
I like the comment about the innocence.
I always like to remember what the brilliant, tolerant minds of the left have to say. In this case, Joy Behar:
"A lot of them are demented when they’re home schooled. They’re afraid of children. They learn to be scared of other children. It’s all about mommy and daddy.”
(The View, 20 November 2008)
It is clear the system has been hijacked by degenerates.
I'm not sure of the reason that home schooling is a criminal act in Germany but it does smack of state control and that was the essence of the Hitler Youth Corps. As with the Stalin equivalent. We have organizations in America that tout and teach the values of American society but they are ALL voluntary – that's why I thought of Hitler – no freedom.
The loss of an objective MSM is one of the greatest tragedies of the 1990s/2000s.
There are tremendous social and economic costs for the people no longer being able to trust our news sources.
We are the revolution.
ObaMarx wants to be the cornerstone upon which the Thousand Year Democrat Plantation is built.
Maybe if they had come here illegally, the Left might be more supportive of them.
It was. But I knew I was going to take it on the chin for that comment. Besides, what kid likes to study? And now they were being forced to study extra just so some photographer could take their picture. It's actually pretty unfair.
And since these are home school parents, you know what happened the second that reporter left. "Well kids, I know it's a Saturday and you really want to go play, but since you already have your books out, why don't we just do a couple of lessons."
Totally unfair.
Yes, because if you ridicule them and tell people they're mentally unhinged, then the fact that they test significantly higher than those who come out of the public education system will hopefully get buried in the white noise.
Next, Behar will probaby be telling everyone that Jaycee Dugard was actually home schooled by Phillip Garrido which is proof that home schooling is dangerous. Yeah for Joy Behar. She has the mental prowess of a fish.
[...] (Kudus: Big Journalism.) [...]
When the US recognizes home schoolers as a persecuted class eligible for immigration, it's only a matter of time that suddenly there are many people faking home schooling as a means to enter the US. As a Russian friend told me, when the US started allowing asylum to persecuted pentacostals , there was a huge surge of Russians joining the Pentacostal church and receiving US immigration status fraudulently. As to the German home schoolers, I'd rather see those immigration slots go to people with more desparate claims, such as brutal torture, rape, systematic genicide.
It's just a mater of time before home schoolers are denied entrance to colleges and universities. Many are dropping the SAT and ACT as part of the entrance requirements because those are test that reveal the effectiveness of a childs education and home schooled kids usually do well on them. So how do you negate the benefits of home schooling, by not testing the students for college entrance. As soon as they come up with some other criteria home shoolers will be denied because they "Lack the social exposure" to possibly be good students at schools and colleges that receive most of there money from the government.
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by CO2HOG: via @BigJournalism Homeschooling German Family Awarded Political Asylum in U.S., Where is U.S. Media? http://bit.ly/crBRgv #tcot…
I didnt know the US government allowed white immigrants into this country anymore.
Hey Folks.
A coin has two sides. I am a Yank and I have been living in Germany for ten years. My child goes to school here. Let me tell you a few positives.
- There are many types of schools to choose from, public, private, montessori, etc…
- My child is taught about Christianity (she goes to a public school). You have three choices between Catholic, Protestant, or an ethics and morality for non-believers.
- There are Crosses and pictures of Jesus hanging in her school (remember it is a public school).
- The German kids are learning English starting in kindergarten
- There would NEVER be a song sung about Chancellor Merkel. It is against the law.
- There would NEVER be any political agenda to indoctrinate students to join groups such as "Organizing for America" It is against the law.
- In the last German elections, the German people voted in the political party that most favored a "Free Market System" as opposed to what was done back in the States.
No place is perfect. If you guys are uptight about home schooling, you are gonna love this. A friend of mine here is married. He and his wife were separating. She started fooling around and got pregos in a fling. The baby came before the divorce. By German law, because he was still married, my pal is the official father even though the divorce is now final. He is finnacial responsible until he can prove (DNA) he is not the biological father. And even then it is still a difficult and expensive process…
Like I said, no place is perfect and home schooling is "verboten".
With the Germans behaving in this manner towards Home-Schooling, and having people's children arrested over it, it 's not so hard to see how Nazi Germany came about. Fascists.
"Give me four years to teach the children and the seed I have sown will never be uprooted."
Vladimir Lenin
"Education is a weapon, whose effect depends on who holds it in his hands and at whom it is aimed."
Josef Stalin
"The education of all children, from the moment that they can get along without a mother's care, shall be in state institutions at state expense."
Karl Marx
"We must create out of the younger generation a generation of Communists. We must turn children, who can be shaped like wax, into real, good Communists…. We must remove the children from the crude influence of their families. We must take them over and, to speak frankly, nationalize them. From the first days of their lives they will be under the healthy influence of Communist children's nurseries and schools. There they will grow up to be real Communists."
Communist Party Education Workers Congress – 1918
Indeed! I feel it!
My husband too! Small business drives the economy of America!
Double dittos!
If you are referring to FDR and his many unconstitutional policies, you're correct in the notion that the USA was somewhat on the side of Communism back then.
The problems with homeschooling
1: sometimes parents dont care they simply do it for illogical reasons and therefore the child suffers because the course work is far to easy
2: ultra-religious homeschooling therefore the child isnt allowed to progress to a college lvl and become success and a critical thinker (martin “Reason is the greatest enemy that faith has," )
3: lack of social exposure
now i agree if the parents provide a highly scientific/philosophic education thats better than public schools (public schools differ region to region state to state new england area being the best)
but more often than not homeschoolers in the United states completely butcher any chances the child has of rising above there current social position by teach them butchered science and altered history
As a political conservative, molecular biology PhD and father of two homeschooled children let me chime in on this one. The DATA show that homeschooled children OUTPERFORM the average American student. The reason should be obvious. One of the best predictors of educational success is parental involvement in a child's education. If one parent is willing to forgo employment so as stay home and educate children then it is a given that these kids will blow the public school kids out of the water.
How much of your opinion is based on actual homeschoolers that you know, and how much is based on the "conventional wisdom" that comes from the media and public schools? Just wondering, because I know a lot of homeschoolers from all kinds of social, religious, and educational backgrounds and I've only met one person that would qualify for your #1 (never met anyone who qualified for #2 or #3).
The real problem here is that our immigration and asylum laws are a JOKE. Immigration into a America has become a "BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY" racket. I am for freedom of choice, but we as a nation just got played.
Ah, the Germans. When I was stationed there, we used to say that Germany was a great and beautiful country, if it wasn't for the Germans. They are so easy to get along with when (a) you have your foot on their neck, or (b) they have their foot on yours.
Actually, home schooling is suprisingly easy to do in California. Not ast restrictive as many states that you would think of as a more homeshool friendly.
I stand corrected. I thought I had read the teacher's unions were making inroads on their efforts to shut down home schoolers.
Lefty establishment tripe meme.
Even the "best" system cannot be all things to all people. That's no excuse for the way they treated this family.
What could be worse than the State taking away your children for no good reason?
"There would NEVER be a song sung about Chancellor Merkel. It is against the law.
- There would NEVER be any political agenda to indoctrinate students to join groups such as "Organizing for America" It is against the law.
- In the last German elections, the German people voted in the political party that most favored a "Free Market System" as opposed to what was done back in the States."
WOW!
Those things run counter to Obamunism.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Vince Humphreys, Homeschool News, Sherry Marquez, libby sutherland, greychampion and others. greychampion said: newStream ©: Homeschooling German Family Awarded Political Asylum in U.S., Where is U.S. Media? http://bit.ly/avhplK [...]
This is great news and I certainly hope there is a flood of hard-working Christian home schoolers who immigrate. Home schoolers do WAY better in college and in life than the products of government schools.
This is our first year homeschooling, and I was concerned that I was not teaching him enough. So I looked up the curriculum map for our school district and figured out that he is working at a 2nd and 3rd grade level for most subjects. We have our ways of tracking the course of work. We also test regularly. Butchered science? My child is operating on a 4th and 5th grade level of understanding. I wasted my money buying first grade curriculum this year. As for butchered history. Did George Washington really chop down the cherry tree? That is just one of the butchered things my public school taught me. My parents should have dropped me off at the library every day for school then went to work. I could have done a better job on my own without those so called "certified teachers". Furthermore my child was reading at 3 years old and a public school had nothing to do with that. I bet you are a liberal. Go google "liberals are mentally ill".
haha, Clint Eastwood is so wild! I love him.
Hey could I reference some of the insight from this entry if I provide a link back to your site?
You must be logged in to post a comment.